The Color Out of Space is one of my favorite H.P. Lovecraft stories. It’s genuinely scary and a great place to start if one were wanting to get into Lovecraft’s weird fiction. It helps that it doesn’t have as much of the virulent racism, misogyny and xenophobia one has to contend with in many of his other famous works.
The story concerns a meteorite that crashes into the Gardner family farm in the rural area outside one of Lovecraft’s many fictional New-England townships: Arkham, Massachusetts. The interstellar rock gives off a strange light outside the visible spectrum, and eventually poisons and warps everything around it.
Richard Stanley’s new adaptation is his first feature since Marlon Brando drove him crazy in the making of The Island of Dr. Moreau back in 1996 (if you haven’t seen the documentary about the making of this film and the unmaking of Richard Stanley I highly recommend the documentary Lost Soul: The Doomed Journey of Richard Stanley’s Island of Dr. Moreau). His new movie seems to me to be something of a triumphant return.
It’s surprising to me that The Color Out Of Space has been adapted at all, let alone more than once (the 2010 German adaptation Die Farbe is excellent). Lovecraft has something of a spotty record with adaptation, largely I’d suggest due to how un-cinematic his stories are in the first place. The horrors in Lovecraft’s tales are always about the unknown and indeed the unknowable. The titular color in this story is referred to in the text as being “only a color by analogy“… I mean… so, what the fuck is it then?! Well, that’s sort of the point in his writing. So, to try and take a thing thats chief descriptor in the source material is that it’s indescribable seems challenging to say the least. Lovecraftian horror, in my estimation, stems chiefly from two things: DREAD and THE WEIRD
THE WEIRD is that which I’ve already described. It’s horror of the uncanny, indescribable nature of what is being observed. Phenomenon from outside the bounds of human understanding. Ancient, elder Gods unbound by the laws of physics as we understand them and completely uninterested in the goings-on of a species so beneath them as the human race.
DREAD is slow, creeping, unsettling horror. The slow-burn, where something just feels slightly off and by turns grows more upsetting and the tension builds and builds and builds until it explodes in a crescendo of existential PANIC. There aren’t a lot of jump-scares or gross-outs in Lovecraft. The horror comes on slow, the weirdness mounts and elevates until it’s rattling the windows of sanity itself. These are both difficult things to pull off in a movie. Especially in modern mainstream cinema which rarely allows the silence and slowness necessary to really build a mood.
Richard Stanley’s Color Out of Space seems to focus mostly on one of these aspects: THE WEIRD. There’s not a lot of “creeping dread” in the film and any cosmic nihilism is mostly implied. After a short intro THE WEIRD starts to ratchet up FAST. Of all the Lovecraft films I’ve seen this one definitely delivers the weird. Fantastic lighting, good creature design, some really excellent performances from the whole cast (particularly Nicolas Cage who, as always, really makes some CHOICES that deliver in spades) and a really tremendous final act make it a very enjoyable ride. I highly recommend it, I suspect it will be unlike most films you’ve seen before.
If you think creeping dread would be more to your taste I would again heartily recommend the 2010 adaptation Die Farbe which doesn’t have the budget to get too WEIRD (though it does pretty well considering its scale) but definitely delivers the DREAD.
I understand Stanley plans to adapt The Dunwich Horror next, another very strong Lovecraft story, so hopefully this one did well enough to convince whomever needs convincing to give him the money to do it justice.
I have a great deal of notes on Lovecraft and his writing so I expect I’ll revisit the topic here in the future.
Currently Playing: David Bowie – “Heroes”
Currently (still) Reading: SLOW HORSES, Mick Herron