Rewatched Ernst Lubitsch’s “To Be Or Not To Be” last night.
It’s one of the best comedies ever made. One of the great examples of angry comedy. A brilliant satire set in Warsaw in 1939. It’s about a troupe of actors who get involved in a plot to stop a nazi spy from handing over information on the underground to the Gestapo. It has extremely high stakes and you can’t get much more serious subject matter and yet is a blast to watch and riotously funny.
Jack Benny and Carole Lombard are extremely funny as the two leads: a married actor couple in the theatre troupe, but the funniest character is the Gestapo Col. Erhardt played by Sig Ruman, his delivery and facial expressions are sublime. I’ve never heard or seen any confirmation of this, but it seems to me that character and his portrayal are the inspiration for both Col. Klink and Schulz from Hogan’s Heroes.
I was surprised to learn that although now it’s considered one of Lubitsch’s best films, at the time of its release To Be or Not To Be was not particularly well received by the public, and many critics found it to be in poor taste. This is odd as I would have thought a movie about what fucking shitheads nazis are would have gone over well. If ever there was a group of people deserving of scorn and satire it’s the fucking nazis. Lubitsch managed to make a laugh-out-loud, hilarious comedy set in Warsaw about the nazis that bristles with life, righteous anger, and also has some pretty great slapstick and he did it in 1942!
It was remade 40 years later by Mel Brooks, but I have never seen that version. I’m a big Mel Brooks fan and I often think of tracking it down, but end up just putting on the original again. I really don’t see how you could top it.
Currently Playing: Northumbria – “Vinland”
Currently Reading: FOLK HORROR REVIVAL: CORPSE ROADS, Andy Paciorek